CUSTOM PIE ORDERS
We make ice cream pies for all sorts of occasions. You pick your favorite cookie crust, ice cream flavor,
sauce, and topping and we’ll make it just the way you like it!
Note: We require at least 3 business days notice* for most pie orders. Please place your order by end of day Wednesday for pick-up over the weekend.
Please call our shop with any questions or send us an email to place your order –
* November 2022: We are not able to accept any custom pie orders between November 15-November 27, 2022. The next available date for a custom pie pick-up is November 30.
* December 2022: Due to the number of pies we make for Christmas we are not able to accommodate any custom pie orders between December 19-27. If you would like a custom pie for an event in this time range please send us your order by December 12th and please plan to pick it up prior to December 19th. Thank you for your understanding!
We make holiday pies in November and December.
November: *SOLD OUT* Thanksgiving pies will be available for pre-order starting on Thursday, November 10. All Thanksgiving pies must be picked up on Wednesday, November 23. Please place your order by clicking here.
December: White Chocolate Peppermint Bark Pies are now available to pre-order. Please place your order by clicking here. All Christmas pies must be picked up on Friday, December 23. If you would like a White Chocolate Peppermint Bark Ice Cream Pie the week before or the week after Christmas please place a custom pie order by emailing firstname.lastname@example.org.
Please note that we are CLOSED on Mondays and on Thanksgiving/Christmas day. We also close early on Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve.
Please email email@example.com with any questions regarding pies.